Best Pizza on Siesta Key

Best Pizza on Siesta Key

Pizza may be the most popular comfort food in the United States.  In fact, Americans eat one-hundred acres of pizza every day.  There’s no reason that vacationers should go without a slice or two on vacation.  Siesta Key has some amazing places to get a pizza pie and they rival anything you can get in New York or Chicago.  Here is our guide to the best pizza on Siesta Key.

Pizza N’Brew

6645 Midnight Pass, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 349-4490

Pizza N’Brew serves up New York-style pizza by the pie or by the slice, plus other food items, plus 36 beer taps and a wine and full liquor bar.  The slices are big and the flavor is great, especially their marinara sauce.  They also host weekly events like trivia, live music, and a fun nightlife atmosphere.

Il Panificio

215 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 800-5570

Il Panificio’s specialty is authentic Italian thin-crust pizza from homemade dough and the finest cheese, sauce, and ingredients they can find.  Many people swear their pizza is exactly what you would find in Italy.  They also serve some of the best Italian desserts in Sarasota.

Ripfire Pizza and BBQ

5218 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 313-7511

Ripfire makes their sauces in-house and sources the best local veggies and meats they can find, so your pizza is the freshest in town.  Some fan favorites include their Heat Wave Pizza, Paradise Pizza, and Smoked Chicken Pizza.  They also make great BBQ dishes too.

Clayton’s Siesta Grille

1256 Old Stickney Point Road, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 349-2800

Although it isn’t technically a pizzeria, you wouldn’t know that from a taste standpoint.  Their brick oven pizza pies are fresh and delicious, and the service is fantastic.  While their pizza selection isn’t the biggest, it is one of the best you’ll find anywhere in the Greater Sarasota area.

Flavios Brick Oven & Bar

5239 Ocean Blvd., Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 349-0995

In addition to some of the best pizza in the city, Flavios also has a great menu of classic Italian cuisine.  However, once you taste their brick oven pizza, you will understand why returning vacationers continue to come back to Flavios, year after year.

It’s good to know that you can still find great comfort food like pizza when on vacation.  Plus, it’s nice to know you won’t have far to drive or walk to get a great pizza pie, right here in Siesta Key.  Just save a slice or two for breakfast.

News & Stories

Best Day Trips from Siesta Key

Florida is a great state to explore by car and these day trips from Siesta Key are worth the short drive.
Read Post

Best Fine-Dining Restaurants in Sarasota

When you feel like kicking it up a notch, these fine-dining restaurants in Sarasota will make you feel like you are on top of the world.
Read Post

Where to Catch Live Music on Siesta Key

If you are looking for the best places to catch live music on Siesta Key, look no further than this list.
Read Post
All News & Stories

Siesta Key Island Rentals

(941) 346-7196